Some infinities are bigger than others

Flying pig to illustrate unbelievable concept of some inifinities being larger than others

Pigs can fly!

Another apparently ridiculous assertion! After all, did I not state in my last post that infinity is a concept that describes something unbounded? So how can anything be greater than something that is unbounded? The answer is that it depends on the way it is unbounded. Lets consider the infinite list of all the positive numbers in sequence 1,2,3 etc. You know that the list is complete because you have not missed any integer. After all, by definition you have listed them in order (2 definitely follows 1 and 3 definitely follows 2 and so on). 

Now think of the infinite list of even numbers listed in sequence 2,4,6 etc. Again the infinite list of these numbers is complete since by definition you have listed them in order. You can now map each number on the first list to each number on the second (1 maps to 2, 2 maps to 4, 3 maps to 6 etc). There is no number on the first list that you cannot map to a number on the second list since any integer can be multiplied by 2 and every number that is divisible by 2 is on the second list. These lists are both unbounded but they are unbounded in the same way (because of this one to one mapping) and are known as “countable” lists. 

Now try and do the same thing with the positive real numbers. You write the first positive real number down ….umm, what are you going to write? Perhaps you think of 0.1 but then you know that 0.01 is less than that. So where are you going to start?  You literally cannot write down a list of all the real numbers in sequence as whatever number you start with you have missed out a number smaller than it! As a result you cannot possibly map each integer on our list of integers to a corresponding number on the list of real numbers because whatever real number you choose to map to the integer 1, there is another (actually an infinity of other) smaller real numbers that you could choose to map it to. So you see that the list of all real numbers is not even countable and therefore it is a bigger infinity than the list of all positive integers (or the infinite list of any other countable things). You think that must be it, but what is even more astonishing is that mathematicians have identified lists that are even more unbounded than the list of real numbers. Good grief, my head aches…time to stop!

Is infinity + 1 > infinity?

Light display image of the mathematical symbol for infinity to illustrate a post about inifinity

Photo by Freddie Marriage on Unsplash

What about infinity plus a million? You guessed it:  they are equal. Infinity + 1 = infinity plus a million = infinity! This does seem counter intuitive until you recognise that you are only lured into thinking that infinity plus something is bigger than infinity because you are unconsciously treating infinity as a number, which it is not. Infinity is an expression used to describe a concept of something that has no bound. This is not something that we are used to handling within our highly bounded 3 dimensional physical  world! 

Indeed “infinity plus one” is virtually the same as saying “imagination plus one” and only appears to make slightly more sense because we know that the number line is also unbounded and we are usually first exposed to infinity in that mathematical context, which understandably establishes a connection between the two in our minds. Notwithstanding, the connection is certainly not that they are both numbers!

Revision!

Navigating revision in tutorials

Revision can be seen as a chore, a thankless trudge through familiar (or frustratingly unfamiliar!) territory. I seek to turn that perspective on its head in this article for The Access Project (TAP) tutors. Just click on the frustrated student below (photo with thanks to Jeshoots.com, Unsplash) to discover my approach to helping students navigate revision in tutorials.

Woman biting pencil while sitting on chair in front of computer

Maths and music

There has long been a suspected link between mathematics and music with some suggesting that learning an instrument promotes mathematical ability and others convinced that it works the other way around (check out this article from the Scientific American). In keeping with that theme here is Brazilian pianist Elaine Rodrigues demonstrating the type of resilience under pressure that would serve any budding mathematician well as they grapple with some unforgiving algebra!